I used the larger rubber seal on the pan and always had a small oil leak. Was ready to drain the oil pan and noticed the plug screw was not real tight. I know I tightened the screw seal and screw.
Walter
When I worked at the dealer we got a NEW plug/washer with EVERY oil change.
They are not that expensive but check the seal everytime if you are going to re-use more than once.
Thanks for the Reply, I always use a new screw with a new washer, they seem to work loose. It could be the temperature difference.