Rob,
At this stage I think you have to believe that the various Jaguar Spare
Parts Catalogues are CORRECT, unless and until you can PROOVE otherwise.
Over the years many times have I jumped to quickly to the conclusion that I
thought the SPC was wrong, only to later find out that I had misinterpreted
something.
I this case I still think that the SPC has not yet been proven wrong, but I
agree that it was a complex few years 1949-56 when Jaguar seemed to go
through three variations of Self-Locking Nuts, but as per Terry McG
observation re the Mark V/XK120 steering-box Nut, it’s hard to doubt Jaguars
diligence towards accuracy, when three revisions of their XK120 SPC includes
part number changes to reflect the evolution of these three styles of
self-locking nut used for the exact same application. I should do the
same for Mark V, but certainly for XK120 it shows the danger of assuming the
SPC is in error - if indeed you are referring to the wrong edition.
The XK120 SPC J.8 - first edition dated Oct 1950, p.40 item S.44 shows:-
C.3320/4 Nut on Bolt (the bolt being an NB.143/23D - thus a 7/16" ANF
thread) The XK120 SPC J.8 - second-edition AL1 Oct 1952, p.40 item S.44 now
shows as:- C.3968/4 Nut on Bolt (same NB.143/23D), so that tells us that by
Oct 1952 the C.3320/4 Philidas self-locking Nut had been superseded by the
AEROTIGHT split-beam type self-locking Nut.
Third edition J.8 - AL2 May 1953 remains unchanged still a C.3968/4 Nut on
Bolt.
Fourth edition J.8 - AL3 June 1954, p.40 item S.44 now shows as :- C8150/8
Nut on Bolt (same NB.143/23D), so now by June 1954 the AEROTIGHT split beam
self-locking-nut was now superseded by a NYLOC 'nylon-insert type
self-locking nut).
Now on top of this I agree, Jaguar only changed their part number if the
new/superseding part was not considered to be 100% functionally
interchangeable, so that also tells me that as you now have, we need to
adopt a unique description for the C.3320/x ANF threaded self-locking nut
that the J.7 Mark V SPC tells us was made/supplied by PHILIDAS.
This is now circumspect given period adverts showing that PHILIDAS also made
at least two other styles of self-locking Nuts - the
(thin-twin-horizontal-slit) turret style, and their Industrial Nut, and I
agree we have yet to see any period Philidas (or any other company)
picture/advertising for the (six-vertical-piece) turret nut. But until I
see proof otherwise, I still find it useful to refer to these as PHILIDAS
(albeit we need a trade name as well)
I don’t have first hand experience with Mark V Nuts, but I do with a 1951
Mark VII that I fully stripped a totally complete/original
driveable-low-mileage-rust-free- car, purely to salvage any parts useful to
my XK interests (I know sacrilege - but for $50 - suited my needs), and in
doing so collected only these (six-vertical-piece) turret self-locking nuts
from all areas that the 1951 Mark VII SPC identified as being C.3320/x part
numbers. By recollection, the only other style of self-locking nut were
the two (per unit) PINNACLE Nuts (as identified in the Mark V SPC) securing
the fuel-pump studs that Jaguar assigned as C2539/1 so different from the
C.3320/x but is that just because of having a BSF thread, rather than ANF,
or was PINNACLE style considered functionally different compared with
(6-vertical-piece) turret style? Again I am happy to call this
top-punched style lock nut a PINNACLE NUT, being re-useable and not prone to
breaking like the C.3320/x nuts.
Now the superseding C.3968/x series nuts, not actually identified by
brand/type name in the SPC, as used on an XK140 are I am 99% positive
AEROTIGHT brand nuts, but are generally grouped/referred to as ‘split-beam’
nuts, which although quite different, is also a term that could be applied
to the Philidas branded (thin-twin-horizontal-slit)Turret Nuts, so maybe
C.3968/x reflects just a ‘split-beam-nut’ initially supplied by Philidas,
but later by AEROTIGHT.
I do not have any Philidas (thin-twin-horizontal-slit) Turret Nuts amongst
all my years of hoarding/salvaging Jaguars, but do have many used
(six-vertical-piece) turret self-locking-nuts and many used (and NOS)
Aerotight Nuts.
So good luck with the Patents searching - always a fruitful exercise.
I really cant add any more at present, but am expecting some new period
technical material in about a month, that may help.
Roger
Roger Payne
Email: @Roger_Payne2-----Original Message-----
From: owner-pre-xk@jag-lovers.org [mailto:owner-pre-xk@jag-lovers.org] On
Behalf Of Rob Reilly
Sent: Friday, 5 June 2015 11:51 AM
To: pre-xk@jag-lovers.org
Subject: RE: [pre-xk] Self Locking Nut Identity
In reply to a message from Roger Payne sent Thu 4 Jun 2015:
Thanks Roger, Roger and Terry for your interest in this topic.
For lack of any definitive trade name I’ll call this nut the six-slot
crimped-over locking-nut. I’ve been looking at British patents 1915-1950 and
have not found it, though I found plenty for the twin-thin-slot turret style
filed by Dundas and Philidas, and various stop nuts by Simmonds. Even a
Belgian patent with Dundas and Philidas together on the title page, so I
think maybe they changed the name of the company about 1945.
So Roger P, is your theory that the Philidas company was selling this
six-slot nut and the turret nut and the industrial nut all at the same time?
I seem to have all three on my Mark V.
I have found this six-slot nut on the following places on my April '50 Mark
V.
bolt through front end loop of rear springs rear shocks to chassis mounting
bolts front upper wishbone large bolts through chassis (but not the smaller
bolts) steering box trunnion bracket bolts clutch pedal arm to shaft through
chassis (LHD only)
I have the turret style nut that appears in all the Philidas advertising on
the Mark V body mounting bolts, upper wishbone small mounting bolts, lower
wishbone mounting bolts, accelerator pedal shaft.
On my Nov '51 120 I have this six-slot nut on the rear shocks to chassis
mounting bolts, front upper wishbone large and small bolts through chassis,
lower wishbone mounting bolts, steering box trunnion bracket bolts.
On a steering column savaged from an Apr '53 120 I have this six-slot nut on
the steering box trunnion bracket bolts.
This six-slot nut has not been found in any period advertising or patents
yet. If it was from Dundas or Philidas they surely would have put it in
their advertising.
Really the only testimony we have of its being Philidas is page 98 of the
Mark V parts catalogue, and the Mark V used many of the turret style which
is unquestionably Philidas.
So at this point I am reluctant to call the six-slot nut a Philidas. The hex
sizes are all SAE so I’m wondering if it could be American? I’ll look in US
patents next.
XK120 FHC, Mark V saloon, XJ12L Series II, S-Type 3.0 --Posted using
Jag-lovers JagFORUM [forums.jag-lovers.org]-- --Support Jag-lovers - Donate
at http://www.jag-lovers.org/donate04.php –