In reply to a message from sfj642 sent Fri 25 Mar 2011:
Jim - I’m very sorry to hear you’re in trouble with this
module again.
Firstly, the device you mention is a fairly common power
MOSFET, good for 50A and 60V. The particular one you mention
is made by SGS-Thomson. I use a Fairchild equivalent in a
few of my controller designs so I have them in stock. If
you’d like to forward your address to me via e-mail, I’ll
gladly put a few in a jiffy bag for you to have a go with.
Secondly - about the recurring problem: When you first
mentioned this module some months ago, it prompted me to go
and find a cheap one on Ebay for research purposes. I found
a working one for �7 which fitted the bill. I’ve analysed
the circuit and I think it’s sorely lacking.
To cut a long story short, there’s a PWM chip which drives
the power MOSFET. In my module, the MOSFET is a BUZ11, which
was an early type and not so robust as later ones. The PWM
chip has facilities for detecting overcurrent and switching
the MOSFET off in that event to protect it. Problem 1: This
feature is NOT implemented in the design. Problem 2: the
MOSFET is the ONLY switching element between the
permanently-live +12V feed and the lighting circuit.
Therefore, if it begins to leak, there is nothing else in
series to disconnect the current. Problem 3: although
MOSFETs make excellent switching devices, they need some
extra protection around them to guard against odd brief
voltage spikes, which will cause (partial or full) failure.
There was practically no protection in the module I analysed.
As you probably already know, MOSFETs have various failure
modes. One such is where they start to leak (i.e., pass some
current when they’re supposed to be ‘off’). Suppose the
MOSFET leaks something like 0.3A at 12V when you believe the
lighting is switched off. That’s not enough to light all
20-odd bulbs on the illumination circuit as they’ll form a
very low resistance, being mostly cold. The leaky MOSFET
appears as a resistor in series with the lamps and most of
the 12V will be dropped across the supposedly ‘off’ MOSFET.
Result: heat!!! And no way of disconnecting the flow,
either. The current is not enough to blow the fuse, so that
stays intact. But it is enough to start a cooking process in
the module. And, even if it doesn’t immediately cook, the
battery will run down, seemingly inexplicably, faster than
it should when the car is unused for a few days.
One item on my ever-growing ‘To-do’ list is to finish a
re-design of this module so that there’s another switching
element in series with the MOSFET, and also proper current
limiting and protection. But you know how it is: ‘real’ work
keeps on getting in the way…
Hope this sheds some light, anyway! (And sorry about the pun.)
Cheers,
Gerald.–
The original message included these comments:
I am not having any luck with the Illumination Module
I replaced it last September after it melted and nearly
caused a fire
So what gives - I don’t think the car wiring is at fault as
I tested it thoroughly last time. Could be a bit of chafing
somewhere - but then why didn’t it blow the fuse ?
Took the unit apart and the power transistor is marked
PSSNF06
–
1996 X300 4.0
Suffolk, England, United Kingdom
–Posted using Jag-lovers JagFORUM [forums.jag-lovers.org]–
–Support Jag-lovers - Donate at http://www.jag-lovers.org/donate04.php –