Thanks Joe, and perfectly fair question,Frank!
I didn’t say we go to work with the airplane, or start hauling
PAX…just that we don’t take the cylinder off (aircooled engines
with separate cyl.'s) until we’ve flown it again or done a run-up.
It’s implied that after we give it a chance and it’s still low we
change the cyl.
We use the differential guage…80 lbs in and hope for 80/80 but
78/80 is beautiful and 65/80 is probablly some crud off the spark
plug threads when you pulled it and then the 80 lbs blew it under the
valve when you brought it up to top center.Then it even happens that
we’ll thump the rocker arm and see if will bump a sticky valve
loose…then it’s ime for mystery oil!
If all that fails then it’s a half day and over $2000 to change it!
and if you turn it upside down on the dock and fill it with gasoline
and it holds it overnight then you have more “experience”!
I’m sure you got my point; run it again before you condemn it.
To put a fine point on it, I’m talking to someone with a car with a
low cyl. and trying to encourage him to give it a fair shot at
healing based on similar experiences.Too many times the cyl is
pulled, sent for overhaul, and nothing wrong!
I’ve run radials for 51 years (since 1956) and changed uncounted
cyl.s and have no statistics for you!
But I’ve learned to run it or fly it before I condemn it!
I think that’s in line with your basic philosophy as I’ve gathered it
since I began reading your posts …
So no hard feelings Frank!
I hope I’ve evaded you…at no risk to you if you are ever a
passenger of mine (big smile !!)
You’ll just have to learn to trust me…
BillOn Sep 26, 2007, at 6:50 AM, joeaksa@attglobal.net wrote:
Frank,
When we are talking about a 9, 18, 28 or an engine with more
cylinders, one cylinder
being a bit low is not unusual. Also we are not talking about an
awful lot of
compression on these engines, with many being around 7.0-1, not the
9.0-1 that we
are used to in our Jaguars. The compression in my aircraft engine
is 6.7-1, so not a
lot of compression there at anytime.What Bill mentioned is usual treatment when a cylinder is lower
than some of the
others after sitting over winter. The test flight is “in the
pattern” as he said, and that
means within easy landing distance of the airport. This is done
after a descent
ground run and if everything else feels ok the best way to check
the engine out is in
the air.Also remember that many of these engines cannot be run at full
power, or at least
cannot be run at full power for long on the ground. The brakes
simply will not hold the
airplane at full power on the ground, so for a real test it has to
go into the air.If there is a real doubt, we never take off, period. If we are
trying to get the carbon
out or exercise a cylinder to see if its going to come back to
normal pressures, then
what Bill mentioned is acceptable.Joe A
A&P (aircraft engineer)
ATP (airline transport pilot)
Jag ownerOn 26 Sep 2007 at 20:26, Frank Andersen wrote:
William de Creeft wrote:
On piston aircraft engines where we do compression checks every 100
hours, I ignore a low reading on a single cylinder,especially if it
has been sitting over a winter or something. Same with valve
settings.
Fresh oil and a few hours running or even once around the pattern
and
recheck that same cyl. will usually do it.Which makes me wonder why the check is done, Bill - and if you
take off
in this condition…The Air Firce catchphrase used to be; ‘if there is doubt - there
is no
doubt’…?Frank
===================================================
===================================================
The archives and FAQ will answer many queries on the XJ series…
FAQs: http://www.jag-lovers.org/xjlovers/xjfaq/index.html
Archives: Jag-lovers Forums - Jag-lovers
To remove yourself from this list, go to Jag-lovers Forums - Jag-lovers.
// please trim quoted text to context only